Published May 2, 2024

5 Mistakes Short-Term Rental Buyers Make in Northern Michigan

Author Avatar

Written by Geno D'Angelo

Short-term rental mistakes in Northern Michigan

Quick answer: The biggest mistakes short-term rental buyers make in Northern Michigan are not checking local rental rules, skipping a market analysis, underinvesting in marketing, neglecting guest experience, and underestimating costs like second-home property taxes, cleaning, management and winter upkeep. Confirm the city, township and association rules before you write an offer.


Investing in a short-term rental property in the enchanting region of Northern Michigan can be a thrilling prospect. However, before embarking on this exciting venture, it's essential to be well-informed about potential pitfalls. Geno D’Angelo, your local Northern Michigan real estate agent, is here to guide you through the crucial aspects of short-term rental ownership. If you're considering purchasing an investment home, this blog post is a must-read.

1. Not Understanding Local Regulations:

Every township, city, and neighborhood has its own set of rules governing short-term rentals. For instance, downtown Petoskey may have different regulations than Boyne Mountain, where a minimum week-long stay could be required. Some condos might mandate the use of their in-house management company. It's crucial to enlist the services of a local agent familiar with the ins and outs of local rules and regulations.

2. Not Doing a Market Analysis before Property Selection:

A thorough short-term rental market analysis is essential before selecting a property. Understanding the demand and competition in the area is crucial. Factors like location, amenities, and proximity to local attractions play a vital role in attracting bookings and garnering positive reviews.

3. Not Having an Effective Marketing and Online Presence:

A robust online presence is paramount for short-term rental success. Professional photography is a must, ensuring the property looks exactly as advertised when guests arrive. Compelling descriptions, along with listings on popular sites such as Airbnb, VRBO, and Booking.com, contribute to a successful marketing strategy.

4. Not Caring about Guest Experience and Property Management:

Providing an exceptional guest experience is key to success. Positive reviews and a quick response rate enhance your standing on platforms like Airbnb, earning you the coveted SUPERHOST status. Clear instructions and quality amenities, such as towels and bedding, contribute to a positive guest experience.

5. Not Financial Planning:

Financial planning is a cornerstone of long-term success in short-term rentals. Consider seasonal rates, adjust pricing during local events, and meticulously track income and expenses, including cleaning, maintenance, and utilities.

Owning a short-term rental in Northern Michigan can be a lucrative opportunity, offering both a vacation home and an income generator. However, there are critical factors to consider when purchasing and managing such a property. If you're contemplating an investment home, reach out to Geno D’Angelo at (231) 487-6141 for expert guidance.

Before You Buy a Short-Term Rental in 2026

  • Check the rules for the exact address. City, township and association rules can differ on the same lake.
  • Budget for second-home taxes. Rentals and second homes don't qualify for Michigan's Principal Residence Exemption, and taxable value uncaps after a sale.
  • Run the numbers at today's rates. With mortgage rates around 7% in 2026, cash flow is tighter than it was a few years ago.
  • Look for year-round demand. Homes near skiing, golf and towns with winter events rent more months of the year.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are short-term rentals allowed in Northern Michigan?

Sometimes. Rules vary by city, township and association, and some areas restrict or license short-term rentals. Always confirm before you buy.

Do short-term rentals pay higher property taxes in Michigan?

Rental and second homes don't get the Principal Residence Exemption, so they pay the school operating millage that a primary home is exempt from.

Where do short-term rentals do best in Northern Michigan?

Areas with year-round draw, such as towns near ski resorts, golf and popular lakes, tend to rent more months of the year.


About the author: Geno D'Angelo is a top 1% Northern Michigan real estate agent with Real Broker and more than 20 years of experience. He specializes in luxury, waterfront, resort, and second-home properties in Petoskey, Harbor Springs, Charlevoix, Boyne City, and Bay Harbor.

Call or text: 231-487-6141
Email: Geno@GenoDAngelo.com

Categories

Second Homes & Vacation Rentals
Agent profile image in chat bubble
Agent profile image in chat header

Geno D'Angelo

Broker / Owner | The Geno D'Angelo Group

Agent profile image in message

or another way